
555 represents the number of sonatas attributed to the C18 composer Domenico Scarlatti. So when the skilled French cabinet-maker, Grégoire Coblence, finds an apparently old musical score hidden in the lining of a cello case that he is repairing, could it be the 556th? He is a gentle man, struggling to accept that his wife has left him, and no musician, but his love of Scarlatti’s sonatas rekindles his enthusiasm.
His Italian business partner, Giancarlo Albizon, expert repairer of ancient instruments has a rather more mercenary interest. An inveterate womaniser with gambling debts, he sees an opportunity to make some money, although the sale of an instrument he is in the process of making would probably have proved more lucrative.
Manig Terzian, an elderly but still immensely talented harpsichordist is ideally qualified not only to play the mysterious piece but to judge its authenticity, likewise Rodolphe Luzin-Farge, an unpleasant but well-known musicologist, specialising in Scarlatti – similarly Joris de Jonghe, a wealthy Belgian collector with a passion for Scarlatti has the funds to research whether the score is genuine.
The story progresses with each chapter presenting one of these five characters in turn – hence another reason for the title. There is also a sixth chapter in the rotation for an anonymous character, who seems to be playing a rather sinister “puppeteer’s” role, manipulating the five protagonists.

Hélène Gestern must have put a good deal of research into this novel, which is a kind of literary thriller with skilfully placed clues and red herrings, and strong development of the main characters, their virtues and flaws, very realistic reactions and indications of how past events may have shaped them. Perhaps the novel is a little too long (464 pages in paperback) with some of the speculation over the score being rather dry and over-detailed.
For the most part, I found this an intriguing page-turner, despite pausing to listen to some Scarlatti, and deciding I didn’t much care for his music – too many frantic notes – so why the obsession with him? So I am not sure whether this proves a “marmite book” dividing classical music lovers from those who dislike it altogether, or know little about it.
Although I found the ending quite unsatisfactory, in this case tying up the loose ends rather too neatly in a lengthy explanatory letter, much of which one could not have deduced, I recommend this novel for individuals and book groups, including for non-French readers. Basically easy to read, the narrative flows along with many interesting turns of phrase, but care is needed to note the rather complicated names of the main characters in order to keep track.











